Southern Nevadans should pay special attention to emergency spillways now collapsing at the nation’s highest dam in northern California. Those people whose homes, property and livelihood hang in the balance below Lake Oroville could someday be us.
The Colorado River infrastructure we so heavily rely on is patched together with the same hope of beating nature in a game of engineering and water management roulette that science tells us will eventually come up double-zero.
For 15 years, the Southwest has been consumed with concerns of water shortages and drought in what many argue represents a new normal for surface water constraints driven by climate change.
Lost amongst these scarcity fears, however, lies the other end of the hydrologic spectrum.
Floods are a dynamic force that shape the Colorado’s course to the Gulf of California. Just five months ago California was still struggling with its worst drought in modern history, now it’s having trouble safely holding water back. Scientist warn that climate change aside, the same can happen on the Colorado.
The most recent flood approaching the observed 100-year average on the Colorado occurred 130 years ago. In 1884, twice the average annual flow of the river passed through Grand Canyon from April to July. The current system has yet to face half of this water volume — and when it did in 1983, the spillways at Glen Canyon Dam above Grand Canyon National Park nearly collapsed.
The hydraulic pressure tore through the spillways’ concrete tunnels, eroding the dam from the inside out. Outside, plywood was erected atop the spillway gates to help hold back advancing waters. Nature relented just in time to head off the dam’s failure, and the contents of one of the nation’s largest reservoirs racing unchecked to an equally full Lake Mead and Hoover Dam.
The Bureau of Reclamation warns that such a release would result in a surge of water through the Grand Canyon of heights ranging from 310 to 570 feet. The torrent would eventually over-top Hoover Dam destroying its hydro electric plant. The plume of water cresting the dam would reach nearly 70-feet and last about 11 days. Hoover Dam it self would be expected to survive, but how and if it along with Nevada’s water intake infrastructure could continue to operate is unknown. Moreover, below Hoover Dam lies much of the water delivery infrastructure for Southern California, Arizona and Mexico, along with one of the most productive agricultural regions in the world. Critical infrastructure including highways, bridges, pipelines, transmission lines serving Los Angeles, San Diego, Phoenix, Tucson and Tijuana would be damaged. The 8,000 square-miles of below sea level farmland cultivated in what’s known as the Salton Sink would likely fill with water that would be trapped for years. Bear in mind, that when Glen Canyon’s spillways failed, they were operating at only 20 percent of their designed capacity. And the combined discharge through the dam’s entire system was but one-third of the estimated 1884 peak rates. While repairs and design modifications have since been made, they have never been tested for these types of flows, nor has its flood-management guidelines been modified to mitigate the likelihood Glen Canyon Dam would be forced to operate under such stress.
Engineers and politicians may have felt they were doing the right thing back in 1956 when they approved Glen Canyon Dam, but it’s long been known to be a risk. Furthermore, billions of gallons of water stored in its reservoir are lost annually to evaporation and seepage into the soft sandstone that surround it. Numerous locations exist to more efficiently store Lake Powell’s water in off-stream, underground aquifers similar to what Las Vegas has been doing for years with surplus water from Lake Mead. And during its lifetime, Glen Canyon Dam has wreaked havoc on the ecosystem of Grand Canyon National Park. In blocking the Colorado’s natural flows, the dam has transformed the aquatic habitat that helped support one of the most unique assemblages of native fish in the world, to one where some of these species have gone extinct and others are just holding on awaiting a return of those natural process that may allow recovery to occur.
With more rains to come, the fate of those below Oroville dam is up to nature, but warnings of its flawed spillways have been known for years.
We must act more proactively on the Colorado. This is why I’m introducing legislation this session that requests the nation’s premiere, in dependent research body, the National Academy of Sciences, to assess the current management practices for the Colorado River, including options for destroying a dam that never should have been built.